CopyCited 1 times | Published | District Court, M.D. Florida | 2002 WL 31094769
...HTE's outstanding stock, at an average price of $2.81 per share. On August 20, 1999, Tyler notified HTE of its purchase of the HTE shares. On August 23, 1999, Tyler provided an "Acquiring Person Statement" ("APS") to HTE pursuant to Florida Statutes section 607.0902(6)....
...The instant Motion concerns the effectiveness and scope of HTE's redemption of Tyler's shares. The issue of the appropriate redemption price and HTE's claim for tortious interference remain for another day. III. THE STATUTE This dispute is governed by Florida's Control-Share Acquisition Law, section 607.0902, Florida Statutes, enacted in 1987....
...When control shares are acquired in a "control share acquisition," [3] the shares do not have voting rights unless a majority of the target company's disinterested shareholders approves a resolution granting voting rights to the control shares. Fla. Stat. § 607.0902(9)....
...Since the statute focuses on a vote of the disinterested shareholders, the act provides a framework for calling the shareholders meeting at which control share voting rights are determined. Generally, the voting rights issue is to be presented at the next special or annual meeting of the shareholders. Fla. Stat. § 607.0902(7)(d). However, the acquiring company can compel a special meeting to be held within 50 days, if it files an APS and undertakes to pay the expenses thereof. Id. at 607.0902(7)(a)-(b). The statute also provides the target company with certain redemption rights with respect to control shares. Id. at 607.0902(10). Section 607.0902(10)(a) applies to a control share acquisition where no APS has been filed. In that circumstance, the target company may, at any time within sixty (60) days following the acquisition, redeem the control shares at the "fair value" thereof. Id. at 607.0902(10)(a)....
...Thus, if the acquiring company wishes to preempt the target company's right to effect an early redemption (presumably prior to a vote of the shareholders), it can simply file an APS. And, by filing an APS, the acquiring company can force an early vote of the target company's shareholders pursuant to section 607.0902(7)(a). [4] Section 607.0902(10)(b) is curiously worded....
...Rather, it reads: "Control shares in a control-share acquisition are not subject to redemption after an acquiring person statement has been filed unless the shares are not accorded full voting rights by the shareholders as provided in subsection (9)." Id. at 607.0902(10)(b). It is this section which is at the root of this controversy. IV. ANALYSIS Tyler contends that HTE's purported redemption of the shares acquired by Tyler is ineffective because its attempt came too late. HTE claims that because Tyler filed an APS, section 607.0902(10)(b) applies, giving HTE an unlimited amount of time to redeem the stock. Tyler's reasoning is that subsections 607.0902(10)(a) and (b) must be read together, and the 60-day provision of (10)(a) must be read into (10)(b)....
..."Ambiguity suggests that reasonable persons can find different meanings in the same language." Pizzarelli,
761 So.2d at 297-98 (citing Forsythe v. Longboat Key Beach Erosion Control Dist.,
604 So.2d 452, 455 (Fla.1992)). Here, Tyler and HTE have argued for different interpretations of section
607.0902(10)(b)....
...CONCLUSION Based on the foregoing, it is therefore, ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that Plaintiff's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment (Doc. 48) is DENIED. NOTES [1] The bill, introduced in 1987 as 87-257, was originally codified at section 607.109, Florida Statutes. Later, it was repealed and re-codified, in its original form, at section 607.0902, Florida Statutes. [2] Section 607.0902(1) states: "Control shares."As used in this section, "control shares" means shares that, except for this section, would have voting power with respect to shares of an issuing public corporation that, when added to all other shares...
...[3] A "control share acquisition" is defined by the statute as "the acquisition, directly or indirectly, by any person of ownership of, or the power to direct the exercise of voting power with respect to, issued and outstanding control shares." Fla. Stat. § 607.0902(2)(a)....